Brad Dourif

Younger Brother

Howard Rollins

Coalhouse Walker Jr.

Elizabeth McGovern

Evelyn Nesbit

Mary Steenburgen

Mother

James Olson

Father

Robert Joy

Henry Thaw

Moses Gunn

Booker T. Washington

James Cagney

New York Police Commissioner Rhinelander Waldo

Kenneth McMillan

Willie Conklin

Pat O’Brien

Delmas, Thaw's Lawyer